top of page

OUR MENU


SANDMAN'S FAVORITE PIZZAS
Handtossed Artisan Crust, Thin Crispy Crust, or Cauliflower (Gluten-Free) CrustCLASSIC CHEESE PIE
House Red Sauce • Parmesan • Provolone • Mozzarella • Pecorino DustMedium
$12
Large
$18
Vegetarian

CLASSIC PEPPERONI
House Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Pepperoni • Pecorino Dust
Medium
$14
Large
$21

MUSHROOM PEPPERONI
House Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Pepperoni • Mushrooms • Pecorino Dust
Medium
$16
Large
$24

HOUSE SAUSAGE
House Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Sandman’s Italian Sausage • Oregano
Medium
$14
Large
$21

SAUSAGE AND GREEN OLIVE CLASSIC
House Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Sandman’s Italian Sausage • Green Olives • Banana Peppers • Pecorino Dust
Medium
$16
Large
$24

MARGARITA WAS HER NAME
Extra Virgin Olive Oil • Light Shallots & Roasted Garlic • Fresh Mozzarella • Fresh Basil • Tomatoes • Pecorino Dust • Coarse Sea Salt Medium
$16
Large
$24
Vegetarian

SANDMAN’S CUSTOM JOBS
Handtossed Artisan Crust, Thin Crispy Crust, or Cauliflower (Gluten-Free) CrustBUFFALO CHICKEN
Buffalo Chicken Breast • Light White Sauce • Sandman’s Buffalo Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Red Onion • Crumbled Blue Cheese Medium
$16
Large
$24

SANDMAN'S BAMF
The tradition continues • House Red and White Sauce • Pepperoni • Sausage • Meatball • Caramelized Shallots & Roasted Garlic • Provolone • Mozzarella • Oregano
Medium
$17
Large
$26

ODE TO THE MAGNIFICENT MUSHROOM
For the serious mushroom fan! House Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil & White Sauce • Sandman’s Wild Mushroom Chop • House Blend of Cheeses • Caramelized Shallots & Roasted Garlic • Pecorino Dust • Truffle Oil
Medium
$17
Large
$26
Vegetarian

CHICKEN BACON RANCH
Sandman’s Ranch Sauce • Oven Roasted Herb Chicken • Provolone • Mozzarella • Bacon • Diced Tomatoes • Red Onions
Medium
$16
Large
$24

BBQ PULLED PORK
Sandman’s Award Winning Pulled Pork • House BBQ/Mustard Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Sandman’s Dry Rub Dusting Medium
$16
Large
$24

BYO PIZZA
Build Your Own MasterpieceHANDTOSSED ARTISAN OR THIN CRUST
12 Inch
$12
+ each add. topping
$2
18 Inch
$18

CAULIFLOWER THIN CRUST
10 Inch
$12
Each Additional Topping
$2
14 Inch
$18
Gluten free

FRESH TOPPINGS
Capocollo Ham • House-Smoked Pork • Bacon • Meatball •
Italian Sausage • Pepperoni • Roasted Chicken • Salami •
Banana Pepper • Bell Pepper • Black Olive • Green Olive •
Caramelized Shallot & Garlic • Fresh Mushroom • Spinach • Fresh Tomato •
Red Onion •
Sweet Onion
SICILIAN TORPEDOS
Sicilian Torpedos
Italian Sausage Wrapped In Our Handtossed Dough • Perfect For Dipping In Our House Red Sauce
$5

SALADS
CLASSIC GARDEN SALAD
Fresh Greens • Tomatoes • Cucumbers • Cheese • Choice of DressingSide Salad
$5
Full Size
$9
Vegetarian

CAESAR SALAD
Fresh Romain Lettuce Chopped • Grated Cheese •
Crouton • Creamy Caesar Dressing
Side Salad
$5
Full Size
$9
Vegetarian

CRANBERRY SALAD
Fresh Spinach • Cranberries • Tomatoes • Almonds • Shaved Red Onion • Crumbled Blue Cheese • Vinaigrette
$10
Vegetarian

ROASTED CRISPY PEPPERONI SALAD
Fresh Greens • Crispy Baked Pepperoni • Shredded Provolone • Mozzarella • Tomatoes • Pecorino Dust Served with Italian Dressing
$10

KETO COBB SALAD
Fresh Greens • Grilled Chicken • Bacon • Hard Boiled Egg • Tomatoes • Onions • Cukes • Cheese • Choice of Dressing
$12

SANDMAN'S ANTIPASTA SALAD
Fresh Greens • Cucumbers • Tomatoes • Capocollo Ham • Salami • Pepperoni • Green Olives • Cheese • Peppers • Red Onions • Served with Sandman’s House Pita
$16

PASTA
BAKED ZITI PARM
Ziti Pasta • House Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella •
Baked to Perfection • Served with Side Roll
$10
Add Sausage or Meatball
Add Sausage$5
Add Meatball$5

SPAGHETTI AND MEATBALLS
Spaghetti Pasta • House Red Sauce • 3 Meatballs • Pecorino Dust • Served with Side Roll
$14

PASTA ALL THE WAY
Ziti Pasta • Extra Virgin Olive Oil • House Italian Sausage •
Shallots & Roasted Garlic • Spinach • Basil • Pecorino Dust
$14

CHICKEN PASTA ALFREDO
Pasta • House Alfredo Sauce • Herb Roasted Chicken
$14

SANDMAN'S CLASSIC HANDHELDS (2 Hands)
Handhelds Offered on Our Italian Roll or on Thin Flat BreadSANDMAN'S ITALIAN
Italian Roll (Baked or Cold) • Turkey • Provolone • Mozzarella • Tomato • Greens • Mayo
$10

ROASTED TURKEY
Italian Roll (Baked or Cold) • Turkey • Provolone • Mozzarella • Tomato • Greens • Mayo
$9

HAM AND CHEESE
Italian Roll (Baked or Cold) • Deli Ham • Provolone • Mozzarella • Tomato • Greens • Mayo • Dijon
$9

THE MEATBALL - REAL DEAL
Baked Italian Roll • Classic Meatballs • Red Sauce • Parmesan • Provolone • Mozzarella • Oregano • Pecorino Dust
$10

ITALIAN SAUSAGE PEPPERS AND ONIONS
Baked Italian Roll • Italian Sausage • Sautéed Peppers & Onions • Splash of Red Sauce • Provolone • Mozzarella • Pecorino Dust
$10

BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP
Italian Roll or Large Flour Tortilla • Buffalo Chicken • Tomato • Greens • Shredded Cheese • Blue-Buffalo Sauce • Ranch Dressing
$9

BBQ PULLED PORK BOMB
Baked Italian Roll or Large Flour TortillaSandman’s Award-Winning Pulled Pork • House BBQ Sauce • Lettuce • Slaw •
Provolone • Mozzarella
$9

Sandman's Award Winning BBQ
We won our first pulled pork competition 20 years ago, and it’s still the bomb!SMOKED CHICKEN WINGS
Sandman’s Award Winning BBQ Smoked Chicken Wings • Smoked with Apple Wood From Our Friends at Lynd’s Fruit Farm • Served with Celery and Choice of House-Made Blue Cheese or Ranch Dressing5 Wings
$8
10 Wings
$15
20 Wings
$28

CHICKEN TENDERS
4 Tenders
$8
6 Tenders
$12

SANDMAN'S PULLED PORK
Meat By The Pound • Served with House BBQ, Fresh Roll & Slaw1/2 Pound
$12
1 Pound
$20

SANDMANS'S BBQ PULLED PORK BOMB
Baked Italian Roll or Large Flour TortillaSandman’s Award-Winning Pulled Pork • House BBQ Sauce • Lettuce • Slaw •
Provolone • Mozzarella
$9

LUNCH ONLY SPECIAL
Only available before 4pmFLATBREAD PIZZA
Choice of 2 toppings
$8

PIZZA BY THE SLICE
$3

SLICE COMBO WITH SIDE SALAD
$8

FLATBREAD COMBO
Flatbread 1/2 Sandwich, Side Salad Combo or Soup/Chili
(Choice of Turkey, Ham, or Italian).
$9

BOWL OF CHILI
$5

SOUP OF THE MOMENT
$5

Discover Westerville's best kept secret, visit Sandman Gourmet Pizza today!
bottom of page